The Home Office Debate: Is It Helping or Hurting?

Lucie Viktorin
February 13, 2025
4 Minute Read

Everyone knows about the infamous home office productivity debate, and most people are impacted by it in one way or another. You’re either for it or against it, and as usual, both sides hold strong opinions. During the COVID-19 pandemic, this debate reached an all-time high, with online-based businesses forced to go fully remote. And while the pandemic was a time full of uncertainty, it also showed that jobs requiring only a computer can be carried out entirely from home without much hassle. So, after proving that remote work is more than just possible, why are so many businesses insisting on employees returning to the office?

The Case Against Home Office

On this side of the debate, many business owners worry that employees won’t be as productive without direct supervision, raising concerns about output and efficiency. There’s also the belief that communication suffers when face-to-face interactions are replaced by virtual ones. Additionally, company culture – often built on shared experiences and physical presence – may weaken when teams no longer work together in the same space.

The Case For Home Office

However, many studies have shown that home office setups can actually boost productivity. Employees with more autonomy over their work environment often experience higher job satisfaction and better focus. Additionally, it enables them to balance their work and private life to a higher satisfactory level. They save time that is otherwise wasted on long commutes, take care of errands during more natural times and enjoy greater flexibility in setting their own schedules overall.

The Impact On Freelancers

Interestingly, the debate about home office productivity has extended beyond traditional employees to freelancers. Some businesses now expect the contracted experts they hire to work on-site or even be fully office-based. This makes little to no sense. Especially in digital fields where 1) location is irrelevant (this is a fact!) and 2) freelancers choose their path first and foremost for flexibility. Requiring them to be physically present contradicts the very essence of independent work.

My Personal Experience

As a freelancer who has spent her fair-share in fully employed positions, I know home office isn’t for everyone. While I’ve always thrived in remote roles, some former colleagues of mines perform better in structured office environments, according to their own assessment. Therefore, offering office spaces as an option definitely makes sense for businesses. That said, forcing adult humans to conform to one rigid idea of the “ideal” work model is counterproductive, if not complete madness. Employees should be treated as the adults they are and given the autonomy to choose the work environment where they thrive best.

As you can see,

the real issue doesn’t seem to be home office work itself – it’s the hiring process or leadership approach. If business owners don’t trust their employees or feel the need to monitor them constantly, they should rethink who they hire or reconsider whether they are suited to run a business at all.

Furthermore, instead of debating whether home office should exist, companies should focus on building trust, improving internal communication and embracing flexibility. Whether for employees or freelancers, remote work is here to stay and businesses need to adapt rather than resist.

If you’re a business owner, remember: productivity and trust go hand in hand. If you don’t trust the people you hire, you won’t create a positive and productive work environment.

And for those home office workers who need a change of scenery, here’s a list of great coffee shops in Valencia – one of the best digital nomad cities in the world! Because let’s be honest, great work and success can happen from anywhere.

Enjoy!

And feel free to share on: